5/11
So today was a really extreme experience. This is my first clinical
experience regardless, and I suspect it will be unlike any hospital setting I
will encounter in the future. Because the hospital is public, I expected that
the facility would be understaffed and primarily occupied by low-income black
African patients. After about an hour drive with Carlien, Lara, and Michelle,
the dietitian who drove us, we finally made it to Botshabelo.
|
The trip to Botshabelo |
I was very
thankful that Hannelise let me borrow her navy blue sweater and red blouse,
because that matched nearly perfectly the uniforms that the other girls were
wearing. The dietitian there, Michelle, first instructed us to complete
nutrition screenings in the maternal ward in order to assess if the program was
adequately addressing all the objectives of the breastfeeding initiatives the
hospital was implementing. I spoke with a woman who had just given birth the previous day and interviewed her about breastfeeding, maternal bonding, and the
education and care she was given. Because Michelle instructed us to also offer
information to the patient, I encouraged her to continue trying to express the
milk, continue keeping the child close to her chest in skin-to-skin contact,
and continue encouraging the child to suckle in a few different positions so
that the baby's suckling will eventually produce the first milk, which I just
said was very nutritious and good for the baby. The woman was very receptive to
the interview and of course very pleased that she had given birth to a healthy
baby even though he was over a month premature.
Then we were sent to the main ward, which hosted various types of patients,
mostly respiratory diseases and pulmonary tuberculosis patients (PTB). With
these patients we were told to screen them by just asking questions and
visually assessing nutritional status, such as estimating BMI and taking note
of any physical signs and symptoms. If we determined the patient to be of nutritional
risk, we were to note any recommendations and report them to Michelle. I was so
thankful for the classes that I had taken during the past spring, particularly
Nutrition Assessment, Advanced Nutrition, and Health Risk Appraisal, because
the information that I absorbed was immensely helpful in assessing patient
needs and determining if the patient would benefit from a nutritional
supplement. I encountered a COPD patient and a bronchial pneumonia/PTB patient who were both very malnourished and clearly feeling terrible, so I recommended
the "peanut butter" supplement called Imunit. Many of the patients
barely spoke English and only spoke a little Afrikaans, so the other students
had to interview as best they could in Afrikaans. I got used to reading the
medical records that sit at the end of each patient's bed, because it was far
easier to assess nutritional status through doctor’s notes than by trying to
decipher Sotho. Even still, the medical records were very scattered and
difficult to interpret. I now truly understand why digital, uniform medical
charting is a need in hospitals. It is very easy for a patient to be given the
wrong treatment when the medical records are unclear and not in chronological
order. I also visited a diabetic woman who only spoke Sotho, but she was not
properly managing her diabetes according to the charts and needed further
diabetes education. However, none of the dietitians spoke anything other than
Afrikaans and English, so we searched through some pamphlets to find one that
she could read in order to give her clear information about insulin injection.
I may try to learn Spanish when I get back to the states, because I realize
that a language barrier in health care truly can mean the difference between
life and death.
The hardest place to visit was the neonatal unit. I was not excessively
emotional, but my heart did fracture in interviewing a mother and reading the
charts of numerous infants diagnosed with PTB or pneumonia and were
experiencing severe malnutrition because his or her mother did not breastfeed the
child for long enough and had switched to diluted formula and pap (porridge)
because they believed it was fine for the child to eat solids at ages younger
than 4 months. The infants had likely contracted the diseases from either
relatives or crèches, day cares that vary from seriously sketchy to reasonably
adequate. I saw malnutrition in magnitudes that are unheard of for the
United States, but more than common in South Africa. Today I saw one baby who
was 9 months old and weighed only 5.2 kg, less than 12 lbs. Her physical and
cognitive development was severely retarded; she was still toothless and
basically the size of a 1 month old. Her aunt was there and the dietitian had
prescribed F75 and F100, a nutrient-dense milk supplement, because the baby was
not yet ready for solid food.
|
F-75 formula supplement |
I saw another baby with PTB and pneumonia who
was experiencing some sort of vitamin or mineral deficiency (likely pyridoxine)
due to her tuberculosis medication interfering with absorption, and at 1 1/2
years old she weighed about 11.6 kg, or about 25 lbs. Her forehead was
flattened in deformity and her eyes and eyebrows tiled downwards so that she
constantly looked sad. Despite my best efforts to cheer her, she maintained a blank,
emotionless face.
|
Staff entrance to the hospital in Botshabelo |
It was in the neonatal unit that I truly realized the weight of my position
as a dietitian. If there is one thing that I would want people to understand
about dietitians, it is that they are health care professionals that do not
exist for the shallow purpose of making people feel guilty for eating chocolate
cake, rather, dietitians exist to save lives because they care about the
welfare their patients and their community. When I changed my major from
occupational therapy to
|
View behind the hospital |
dietetics, (not at all to discount the crucial importance of physical therapies) I never knew that I was dropping the
objective of improving lives in order to pick up the responsibility of saving
lives. It's a pretty heavy feeling honestly. Even still, I believe that this is
the profession that I am called to pursue, because I know that the weight of
life is a bearable burden for Christ, so because Christ is in me, it is a
bearable burden for me. I've been on countless missions trips, led youth and
small groups, participated in numerous dietetic association committees,
volunteered with pretty much any nutrition-related event at Appalachian State,
and even given a sermon series at Wesley called "spiritual
nourishment," but for the first time in my life, I felt abundantly
fulfilled by my actions, like God was approving them by offering me the
opportunity to use the knowledge that I have worked so hard for in order to
tangibly affect and feel the lives of others. And by "feel," I mean
allowing my life to take the shape of the contours of another person's life.
That is the only way I think I can define what true service feels like. I know
it has only been a day, and it was hard and tiring, but I am positive that this
profession is where I am supposed to be.
I tried to express how I felt about the day to Nicole, then Wieda and
Hannelise, but I really wish that Ryan was here. He is wonderful at really
listening with his heart and is probably my favorite person to discuss these
sorts of things with.
On a much less contemplative note, the other roommates are back, and I met
one of the Italians after Nicole and I screamed at the sight of a mouse in the kitchen.
We frightened the poor thing out the front door, but thankfully he came back in
time enough to rescue us from the mouse. I don't remember everyone's name yet, but
I know there is another girl from Holland across the hall, a girl from the
Czech Republic in the room next to mine, and two Italian boys down the hall. You could say that we live in a melting pot. I was hoping I
would meet a student that would go to Cape Town with me, but everyone has
already travelled quite a bit and Nicole is about the only one that I think I
would like to travel across Africa with. The others are a bit eccentric. They
really like to party and have told me many stories of their weekend trip and
other various trips just jam packed with wild fun.
Personally, I find my frontal lobe to be quite useful in hazardous situations,
and I try my best not to offend it.
I also got coffee today at Mimosa Mall with Wieda and Hannelise, which was a
really fun time. Both of the girls are really sweet and have been incredibly
helpful. Wieda gave me her university credentials to log on to the computers,
which I will attempt to use tomorrow, and both of the girls are keen on showing
me the activities and sights of Bloemfontein. I also had just barely enough Wi-Fi
at the coffee shop to send an email to Dr. Jones explaining why she hasn't
heard from me for a while (sorry Dr. Jones!). Anyways, tomorrow I will be at one of the crèches,
or day care centers, and I was told to bring my flexible measurement tape, so
I'll likely be hanging out with Centi. I heard she is nothing special but I'm
still excited to meter.
-Jordan
5/13
Yesterday (Tuesday) I took a break from
the blogging because I was so exhausted from the day. I don't know why the jet
lag is just hitting me now, but waking up at 6:30 am feels very much like 12:30 am to me.
It takes about an hour to get to Botshabelo, so we try to leave by 7:30 am
every morning. My fogginess made yesterday a very frustrating morning, because
as we were interviewing patients my mind was not as sharp or as clever as
usual, which made interpreting accents and responding accordingly very
difficult. Also, we counseled a couple patients in the morning before heading
to the crèche, and I felt generally useless. Lara and Carlien are very good at counseling
because they have had loads of clinical experience, and as of right now I have
about two day's worth of counseling experience. I am still not familiar
with some of the commonly eaten and available foods here, so I fear giving
irrelevant advice or sounding insensitive to the patients. I have learned that
pap is a very common staple for most of the patients and I am also trying to
understand how and where most of the patients obtain their food. So rather than
counseling or educating, I sat and watched the other students counsel patients
for a couple of hours. It was torture because I wanted to help so badly. I
remained patient and tried to remember that I was here to learn, and that I was
learning by watching them counsel. The first patient who came in was a mom
with an 11 month old baby that nearly exclusively ate formula milk and pap.
After the 24-hour recall, Carlien and Lara explained to the mom that the baby
is old enough to be eating finger foods and soft fruits and vegetables. The
baby was significantly underweight, so they continued the baby's
supplementation of Imunut. Another patient who came in for counseling was a
35 y.o. woman who was referred because of her obese classification. The 24-hour
recall was really helpful in assessing where changes could be made. She had
never received any nutritional education before. She ate 4 cups of pap for
breakfast, lunch, and dinner, as well as 2 cups of pap every time she wanted a
snack. Sometimes she would combine the pap with chicken or beef, and most
always she seasoned it with brown onion soup, a commonly used, high-sodium mix.
She maybe ate 1 fruit a day and very rarely ate vegetables. In addition, she
drank 4 litres of soda every day. I wasn't as much astounded that she ate some
much pap and drank so much soda as I was impressed at her iron stomach. If I
ate like that I would definitely hurl. Lara explained to her some easy ways she
could alter her diet, such as reducing the amount of soda she drank and
increasing the amount of clean, safe water as well as replacing some of the pap
she ate as her snack with a fruit or a vegetable. As Lara talked, Carlien drew
a myplate for the lady and labeled all the commonly eaten foods in each
category. I think hand-drawing the plate and hand writing the recommendations
made the information seem a lot more personalized and prescription-like.
Visiting the crèche brightened up my day
as I began to feel useful again and the children there were really adorable. We
couldn't find an operable scale to weight the children with, so we just focused
on mid upper arm circumference (MUAC) and vitamin A supplementation. We were instructed
to sort through about 50 "Road to Health" books, government-issued
books given to all children born in South Africa that mothers are instructed to
keep track of and keep safe. The booklet holds all of the child's immunization
records, growth charts, and medical information. We searched each book for
children aged 5 and under who had not received a vitamin A supplementation in
the past 6 months. Over 2/3 of the children needed their next vitamin A
supplement, so all of the children were sent through our dietetics assembly
line to have their MUAC taken. Those in stack A were sent to Lara and
Carlien to take a dose of the vitamin A. I measured 50 little de-sleeved arms,
each dangling out from under a scrunched-up shirt that revealed 50 little bellies,
about 1/3 of which were abnormally swollen, a sign of protein deficiency. Some
little boys handed me flexed biceps to measure, while a couple little girls
were not sure what I was doing, but were positive that it was going to be some form of torture.
The only doctors in the hospitals and clinics are white, while all the nurses,
the "sisters," are black. Michelle told me that little children only
know white people to be associated with needles or pain. Thankfully, most of
the children were happy to be cared for and maintained their darling smiles. As
we departed, we were bombarded by a fleet of little thumbs, their owners
shouting "shap," which means something like 'all good' in Sotho. We
returned the "shap" by sticking our thumbs and snapping them against
the children's palms. "Dankie, goodbye! Shap!"
When we got back to Bloem I was able to
use Wieda's university credentials to log on to the computers, which was like
taking a breath of fresh air. I was finally able to check my final grades, and
I was pleasantly surprised to find that my semester GPA ended up being a 3.9,
all A's and one B+ in Advanced Nutrition. Not bad for a 19 s.h. workload. At
the point of discovery, my true nature was revealed to my new South African
friends through sudden dancing and cheering. It was mildly embarrassing in
retrospect, but let's be real, if they knew what a GPA was and the same
happened to them, they would be breaking it down in the computer lab too. That
bumped me up to a 3.64, so my day was rapidly re-calibrated to level fabulous.
That is, until I went to the international office to check on my internet
situation. Without going into detail, I think I must have had a really long,
roller-coaster day, because I was not in an emotionally stable state,
especially not in the face of sarcasm. It may have had something to do with having seen malnourished babies all day or missing my family. After the Wi-Fi voucher was sorted
out, Wieda and I went to the grocery store so I could once again take on the
challenge of withdrawing cash. Cash back from shopping with the credit card was
unsuccessful, though I gained a lot of bananas in the process. However, after a
sophisticated process of troubleshooting I like to call "randomized button
input," I was finally able to withdraw 100R from the ATM, which
unfortunately turns out to only be about $8. I'm telling you though, $8 goes a
long way in South Africa. I think I can recreate the process. To get my student
access card, Marleen explained that I needed to pay 65R to the bank while
handing in an account number so that they would give me a receipt that I would
then bring back to Marleen before 3 pm. Since the bank closes at 3:30 pm and I
had no idea when we would be back from the hospital, Wieda said she would do it
for me since her station is on campus this week. I don't know how I am ever
going to properly thank Wieda for all of her wonderful, sweet-hearted help, but
I am brainstorming my hardest.
So today (Wednesday) was a much easier day
at Botshabelo. We were instructed give a breastfeeding presentation and then a
diabetes presentation, both as introductory courses to the topic. The
breastfeeding education was my favorite, because I know that breastfeeding
education is the best way to prevent the severe malnutrition that I saw on
Monday. In areas such as this, breastfeeding is still strongly promoted even if
the mom is HIV positive. We say that as long as the ARVs are properly taken,
there is a very low risk of transmission to the baby. Breast is always best. We
explained that if the mother had cracked nipples or if the baby has sores in
his or her mouth, that the breastmilk should be expressed by hand and heated in
a jar over boiling water for 30 minutes, then cooled before given to the baby.
We also explained how to express the milk by hand by cupping the breast and
rolling the thumb over the glands to release the milk. Instructions for storage
were also given: three days in the refrigerator, three months in the freezer.
It may be convenient even to put the expressed milk in ice cube trays so that
defrosting in a bowl over a simmering pot of water is easier. We also gave
advice on how to position the baby, how to detect signs of hunger, and how
often/long the baby needs to feed (the answer always being "as long as the
baby likes").
|
Patient breastfeeding pledges |
At the end of the session, all of the expecting moms were
offered an opportunity to take the pledge to exclusively breastfeed for the
first 6 months of their baby's life. About half of the 30 women that we talked
to decided to take part by leaving a painted handprint on a signed piece of
paper. The new handprints accompanied several others that already hung on the
wall of the waiting room.
We then headed to another ward of the
hospital to offer diabetes education to a group of about 6 diabetic men and
women, some of which were newly diagnosed. Lara and Carlien explained with
pictures exactly what diabetes is, "when there are not enough keys (insulin) or the
key is rusty, sugar cannot get into the cells to feed your body." They
also explained what glycemic index is, and the difference between low GI
and high GI foods. My part in the demonstration was to play the American
that needed help creating a healthy, low GI plate. The folks
giggled at my accent and seemed to have a pretty enjoyable time explaining to
me why some foods were bad and others were good. I don't normally like
classifying foods as black vs. white, good vs. bad, but for the general
nutritional education level of Botshabelo, it is very important to ring home a
clear message. It was pretty clear that alcohol should be avoided and fruits
and vegetables are better snacks than soda and pap.
I was so thankful that I got to talk to my
dad and Ryan this evening. It was good to hear familiar, encouraging voices. It
was also good to hear that we are selling our beat up old Volvo. If you are
reading this and want something to pray about, pray that I find joy in the Lord
through all circumstances, and pray that I serve as a beacon of hope to those
who have so little. I am praying that my heart remains sensitive to the needs
and wants of others, even the people that are difficult to love.
5/14
|
Michelle outside a clinic in Botshabelo |
Today was my last day at Botshabelo, so I
was a bit disappointed that I didn't get the opportunity to check in on those
babies again. Rather, today we traveled around Botshabelo to various rural clinics
to offer general nutrition education to everyone in the waiting rooms. I didn't
get to present as much as I would have liked, but I am at peace with that. Lara
and Carlien are being graded on their performance, while I am mainly here for
the ride. Also, as soon as I open my mouth, everyone in the room realizes that
I am American, which led to one woman's post-presentation request that I give
her two rands to buy salted peanuts. I dodged the question by telling
her that we don't want to eat the salted peanuts, we want "minder
sout," less salt to stay healthy. Carlien and Lara though it was
hilarious. The presentations were nothing too new, we just went through
explaining the myplate visual and had some volunteers build a healthier plate
for us using the abundance of laminated food in our education bag.
What was really helpful for me in
understanding poor South African foodways was our visit to a massive grocery
store called Rite Brand. As we have been driving around Botshabelo this week, I
have witnessed the surreal pilgrimage of people from miles around walking
through barren grassy fields scattered with garbage and livestock waste just to
get to this store. The landscape in this area is quite eerie and fascinating
actually, because the land is incredibly brown and flat, except for the occasional
mountain.
|
View from just outside a clinic in Botshabelo |
|
Carlien outside one of the clinics |
Mountains are very randomly scattered and
equally barren. All of the plants that grow here, aside from the tall grass,
look fierce with thorns, spikes, spurs, and rough leaves with jagged edges. The
plants honestly look like gladiators who fought for their lives, but remained
merciless and scarred after the battle. South Africa is not an easy place to
live, and the botany is not the only species that has experienced great strife.
The reason Botshabelo experiences such high rates of poverty and unemployment
is because there are very few jobs to accommodate such a massive unskilled
workforce. If you just take a 360 degree look at the surroundings, it is pretty
clear why there are no jobs. Most of the area is barren and undeveloped. There
are numerous cattle and goat roaming regions, several small shanty shack
villages, maybe a gas station, the hospital in the distance, and a giant
grocery store that caters to a vastly unemployed population. Michelle said that
most of the population is unemployed and survives off of child grants, which
accounts for 330R per child per month. In US dollars that is about $28 per
month. For a family with three children that is about $83 per month. Michelle
also said that some women may drink heavily during pregnancy in order to get a
disability grant, which is a slightly larger sum. Health care is free for those
below the poverty line, so nutritional supplements are also free. However, it
is not uncommon for mothers to let their child's weight decline so that they
can go to the clinic to get free supplements that are designed to be eaten in
addition to a nutritious diet, but end up being the child's greatest source of
nutrition. It is clear that families are forced to take drastic measures to
survive in this climate.
How does a population recover from this?
This is where my various interests begin to merge. The only way for a community
to experience an improvement in public health is if the local economy is
stimulated in practical, strategic, long-withstanding ways. This is one of the
many reasons I wanted to volunteer at Bulembu, Swaziland; I want to understand
specific pathways by which a community as a whole can break away from cyclical,
generational poverty. My goal as a dietitian is to help people maintain a
balanced diet and a desirable standard of health if nutritionally applicable.
Though difficult, it is possible for a family to roughly adhere to the
nutritional guidelines provided to them. Breastfeeding is certainly attainable
for infants. Maybe 3 fruits and vegetables rather than 5 per day is attainable.
Maybe cooking chicken without the fat and replacing the salt in pap with pepper
and herbs is attainable. These are guidelines recommended to prevent nutritionally-related
diseases, but it is important to note that constant worry and struggle do not
contribute to a high quality of life, and the worry and struggle will often
occur regardless of nutritional status. So how do we address the root cause of
widespread poor quality of life?
I attempted a causal loop, so bear with me.
All roads seem to lead to
poverty, and all roads seem to originate with poverty. I know that
unemployment is the primary factor that contributes to poverty, but it is also
important to note that unemployment is caused directly by a lack of education,
limited access to resources, a lack of a skilled workforce, a lack of economic
development, and an increased rate of contagious or psychological/addictive
diseases. However, it is indirectly caused by lack of government support for economic
development, malnutrition, obesity, tight living quarters, and a high cost of
living in comparison to income. The primary factor that can directly contribute
to higher employment rates is an increase of economic development that is
spurred by an educated, skilled, healthy workforce. In my opinion, public
education and accountable educational systems are among the best ways to begin
equipping the economy for stimulation in addition to reducing disease rates.
|
Spinach garden outside a Botshabelo clinic |
In any case, we surveyed the prices of
common food items such as maize mill (pap) and various vegetables and fruits to
get a better idea of how far 330R per child can stretch. Not very far, I'm
afraid, though food is significantly cheaper here than in the US. I am going to
continue mulling over the connection between economic development and
nutrition. Bulembu is going to be exceptionally exciting in a few weeks as
their mission is to restore community health, education, and economic
development.
Some additionally important things to
remember about Botshabelo:
1. Always greet the head nurse and the
other sisters before you do anything else.
2. Use visuals whenever possible. Ask the
patient(s) questions to make sure the message was understood.
3. If you ask a patient if they know about
(insert here), and they say yes, ask them what they know. It is highly likely
that they need a refresher course.
4. Research all of the medications that a
patient is taking to make sure that you know what it is, and that it isn't
something that interferes with appetite, absorption, or some other
dietary-physiological factor.
5. Afrikaans is fun to speak initially,
but after a few days the "g" noise is a serious throat hazard.
-Jordan